- Pimps who run the game. They are the professors.
- Escapees who are about to get out. They are (graduates who leave the field but use their skills.
- Losers, who those sucked into the system until their time, youth, and money desert them. They are non-tenure track instructors.
- Disaster tourists, who get a thrill out of the place. They are students or others who for whatever reason don’t need the degree for employment.
Pimps are in zero-sum competition with each other. This conflict leads all pimps to give up freedom in exchange for safety.
Pimps act tough, but only because they are in a dangerous environment. They are prisoners of the lack of jobs and opportunities. There is no freedom in the ghetto.
A pimp may lord it over losers and strut for disaster tourists, but his life is essentially one of fear. Signs of weakness are pounced on. The only safe approach is to stay within your square block, not venture outside, and avoid conflict (while appearing not to). Original thinkers are weeded out, punished, or otherwise compelled to keep their heads down.
A sad example of this occurred this year at the formerly interesting group blog, Duck of Minerva. As I described it in a post from August…
An example of this was at The Duck of Minerva, a blog dedicated to celebrating one alley in the academic ghetto (International Relations). A humorous post on identifying and infiltrating old boys networks by a professor at a research university, Brian Rathburn, entitled “Intellectual Jailbait: Networking at APSA” was taken down, all comments on that post were deleted ,Brian was forced to issue a self-criticism, Brian’s post became a non-entity (substantively replaced by Steve Saideman‘s post “Networking is Hard Work“), and two thinly veiled attacks on Brian were posted, (Daniel Nexon‘s “Sexual Harassment in Political Science and International Studies and Laura Sjoberg’s Let’s talk about sex). .
To go back to the analogy, Brian, Daniel, and Laura were pimps who engaged in a turf war. Steve instead gave in to the system, avoiding conflict with the most generic post possible.
- Brian… blogger at Duck of Minerva, until he resigned
- Daniel… blogger at Duck of Minerva, until he resigned
- Laura… blogger at Duck of Minerva, until she resigned… this week
But Steve — who wrote a generic and grey post, who kept his head down — he’s still there. He even said he likes his job. Brave stuff.