Review of “Fire from the Sun,” by John Derbyshire

“O God of Progress, have you degraded and forgot us?”
Sufjan Stevens

“Do you want to make me hate you?”
French Teen Idol

Heartbreaking. Inspiring. Moving. One-thousand pages.

Fire from the Sun is the best historical fiction I’ve read in more than a decade, since Aztec, by Gary Jennings. . Extrapolating forward, this means there will only be a handful of books in that genre as good, as memorable, or as important before I die, if I make it into old age. Given the quality of this book, that seems fair.

I remember when Fire from the Sun came out, more than a decade ago. I remember reading this post, and quickly being intimidated by the number of volumes required (3!, more than $100 at the time) to read the book. So I put it off until the author, John Derbyshire, made the news for something completely different, and saw that Fire from the Sun was available in an affordable and easy-to-carry Kindle edition.

Fire From the Sun begins in south-west China in 1965, the last year of China’s “long 1950s” (1949-1965) and the year before the Cultural Revolution. As I was in tears the last hour of reading the book, it’s not surprising I find the beginning incredibly moving, looking at it again:

Chapter 1
New Costumes at the Swimming Pool
We Have Friends All Over the World!

The first time Weilin ever saw foreigners, ”real foreigners, not just National Minorities or Chinese people from another province”was at the swimming pool in South Lake Park.

The scope of Fire from the Sun is incredible, and incorporates multiple stories and perspectives of the period. If you’ve seen Chinese cinema of the period, the following themes from famous movies are also reflected in Fire from the Sun. 24 City, From Mao to Mozart, Balzac and the Little Chinese Seamstress, Summer Palace, and Mao’s Last Dancer have clear parallels to the adventures in the book. Non-fiction readers of The Man Who Stayed Behind or I Choose China will recognize the descriptions of Beijing and other towns.

It struck me after finishing Fire from the Sun that the main characters are symbolic of the yellow earth / blue sea debate — though in complex and unexpected ways. In other words, what is the true China: Beijing or Hong Kong? Finishing a work this massive, the first day was spent thinking of the characters and all they went through. With a little more time to think of the book, though, the symbolism behind the story is just as meaningful. But it was the characters that made me cry.

Derbyshire uses the book’s thousand pages to emphasize the patterns behind behavior. This is perhaps most obvious given the two incidents involving different pedophiles, one of which paints the predators in a ghastly light, the other very sympathetically. Additionally, the sees surrounding the Tiananmen Massacre, both involving students being shot and soldiers being burned alive, emphasize how terrible that tragedy was. The same variations on a theme, the same drawing out of the substantial reality under the happenstances, are woven meticulously through the book.

I read Fire from the Sun on the Kindle edition.

5 thoughts on “Review of “Fire from the Sun,” by John Derbyshire”

  1. Any other recommendations for good/fun/interesting historical fiction from those in the “TDAXP book club”?

    I’ll recommend for WW2: “Winds of War” and “War and Remembrance”.

    I have also been enjoying over the years the ancient Rome based historical mysteries by Lindsey Davis and by Steven Saylor.

    I am looking for a big/broad Marco Polo historical fiction.

  2. Well, I have decided to make it one of two ‘fiction’ books I will read this summer. Thank you for the thoughtful review.

    May I add his treatment was disappointing. Much like Buchannan’s forced exile, it is an unfortunate assault on free thought, however controversial it may be to some.

  3. Eddie,

    Excellent! I strongly recommend it. It’s very vivid — I find myself thinking about scenes in it almost every day…

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *